Book Review: SciFi novel
Review: Ringworld
– David Zetland
The one-handed economist
Sometimes you just want the answer
I grabbed this 1970 Sci-Fi novel by Larry Niven based on its recommendation. The book is the first in a series (that I will not continue, given the fact that I am now reading three other series!) on how humans and other aliens explore Ringworld — a belt of the size of Earth’s orbit that occupies its entire circumference. This first book introduces the protagonists, explains why they might want to kill each other, and sets up the science and existence of Ringworld. The story has a lot of interesting surprises, but I’m mainly writing this “review” to copy/paste a number of striking passages.
Before they leave, Louis (the “200 year young” hero) observes life on Earth:
- In three-and-a-half centuries the transfer booths had done this to the infinite variety of Earth. They covered the world in a net of instantaneous travel. The difference between Moskva and Sidney was a moment of time and a tenth-star coin. Inevitably the cities had blended over the centuries, until place names were only relics of the past. San Francisco and San Diego were the northern and southern ends of one sprawling coastal city. But how many people knew which end was which? [Damn] few, these days. Pessimistic thinking, for a man’s two hundredth birthday. But the blending of the cities was real. Louis had watched it happen. All the irrationalities of place and time and custom, blending into one big rationality of City, worldwide, like a dull gray paste. Did anyone today speak Deutsche, English, Francais, Espanol? Everyone spoke Interworld. Style in body paints changed all at once, all over the world, in one monstrous surge.
- A puppeteer explains why his species left its overcrowded world: Earth produces too little natural fresh water for its eighteen billions. Salt water must be distilled through fusion. This produces heat. But our [puppeteer] world, so much more crowded, would die in a day without the distilling plants. “A third example. Transportation involving changes in velocity always produces heat. Spacecraft filled with grain from the agricultural worlds produce heat on reentry and distribute it through our atmosphere. They produce more heat on takeoff.” “But cooling systems—“ “Most kinds of cooling systems only pump heat around, and produce more heat for power.” “U-u-urr. I begin to understand. The more puppeteers, the more heat is produced.” “Do you understand, then, that the heat of our civilization was making our world uninhabitable?” Smog, thought Louis Wu. Internal combustion engines. Fission bombs and fusion rockets in the atmosphere. Industrial garbage in the lakes and oceans. It’s often enough that we’ve half-killed ourselves in our own waste products. Without the Fertility Board, would the Earth be dying now in its own waste heat.
- Louis liked surprises; he was indifferent to power. He was not creative; he did not make things; he preferred to find them.
- [On Ringworld:] The hairy man punched him unskillfully in the nose. The blow was light, for the hairy man was slight and his hands were fragile. But it hurt. Louis was not used to pain. Most people of his century had never felt pain more severe than that of a stubbed toe. Anesthetics were too prevalent, medical help was too easily available. The pain of a skier’s broken leg usually lasted seconds, not minutes, and the memory was often suppressed as an intolerable trauma. Knowledge of the fighting disciplines, karate, judo, jujitsu, and boxing, had been illegal since long before Louis Wu was born. Louis Wu was a lousy warrior. He could face death, but not pain.
- It was all city, hundreds of square miles of city. There weren’t even parks. With all the room on the Ringworld, why build so close? Even on Earth, men valued their elbow room. But Earth had transfer booths. That must be it: the Ringworlders had valued travel time [from point A to B] more than elbow room.
It’s a fun book. FOUR stars.


I read this years ago. It starts out good, but the author runs out of ideas and it becomes boring.
coberly:
There are some I have read where it becomes a matter of forcing yourself to read it, if you can not get into the story or style or approach.
I loved this book. Of course, I loved almost every SF book I read—starting in 1960.
dave
i am curious if you care to share: what is it you llike about sci fiction? the first “grownup” book i read was at about age ten, a copy of Heinlein, Red Planet, I found in the library, of course it was not a grownup book…or was it. I have liked a few more Heinlein since then but gave up about the time he had groupies and let them publish the stuff he threw in the waste basket. A few other Sci Fi I liked included one I can’t find anymore..one about a wolf sun, and one alled Brother Johnathen…all of these presented interesting ideas and “moral” perspectives that resonated. Charcters and dialog (often internal] that were not cloying. Probably not great literature, but for me more fun to read than Brothers Karamazov.
Dale:
I need the other parts to that piece if it is to be posted. You alluded to more to be added to it.
If you have changed your mind, I am ok with it. I do not mind working with you or others to present good pieces.
Bill
Bill, I wrote about fifteen replies to your last letter to me. Are you saying you never got them?
Coberly:
Typically, such writes allow my mind to wander free from present factual accuracy. If you can, finish your piece. If not, I understand. I have done lengthy posts in the past. Making them cohesive can be difficult too.
I HOPW YOU get this and my reply to you above. Try to find a way to reach me. And why you are not getting my emails. I will try one more time to write a very short email with no attachment or copy and paste from sources your server thinks are scam.
dave
i guess that’s why we can’t all just get along.
It’s a good novel with some interesting ideas; Niven’s “Known Space” books in general make up one of the most interesting visions of the future, with some real thought about seriously advanced technology (such as a cure for aging, so that everyone stays alive and youthful for as many centuries as they choose) and what societies with such technology would actually be like. It never veers into clichéd dreary dystopian or post-apocalyptic nonsense.
The review writer is in error on one point, however. The Puppeteer species has not “left its overcrowded world” — they cannot, because part of their normal psychology is a form of racial paranoia which makes them unable to trust space travel. The only Puppeteers that humans have ever met come from a tiny minority which does not have this paranoia and is considered insane by the rest of the species. This point is actually emphasized rather strongly at several places in the novel. For example, at one point other characters wonder if the Puppeteers are plotting to conquer the gigantic Ringworld as lebensraum for their huge population, but dismiss the idea because they would be unable to migrate to the Ringworld after conquering it.
I have read the sequel, which is not nearly as good as the first book. I haven’t read any further in the series, but my experience is that novel series, like movie franchises, tend to deteriorate rapidly compared to the original.
Infidel:
Good to see you again. Thanks for the comment. I am sure David appreciates your comment.
Bill
glad to see you were here. I assume you have given up on the other project. Probably for the best.
Bill
see my reply to your comments above. I have been trying to reach you for three days,
I read Ringworld a billion years ago, and I remember being rather unimpressed. It was very 19th century, sort of lame H. Rider Haggard who at least had a sense of humor and didn’t whine. Haggard also had a healthier attitude towards women than Niven. (Haggard started writing adventure stories after reading a particularly poor one and claiming that he could write a better one. He did. He wrote several more.) A lot of friends were enthralled by Ringworld and Niven. I wasn’t. At best, he was workman-like.
It was only years later that I learned about Graustark. As more and more of the world was linked by 19th century globalization, it kept getting harder and harder to find some exotic location to set an adventure story. In fact, an insightful writer could find surprisingly exotic worlds halfway down the block, but that kind of exotic adventure requires more from the reader than a story set in some elsewhere.
George Barr McCutcheon invented Graustark, an undiscovered part of Mittel-Europe to set his stories. It even had a Cook travel office as one might expect in the early 20th century. Then came space travel which opened up an even more extensive narrative space to be filled by rocket ships and aliens. I grew up with that stuff, and I still enjoy it now and then. I just never warmed to Niven.
Kaleberg:
Thanks for commenting on this review.