Why Would Increasing Sales Be an Indicator for a Poor Economy?

More likely than not, buying at WalMart indicates such because the costs are less. Even now when prices are up, WalMart may still be the place to shop. People may be buying off brands and poorer cuts of meat, Spaghetti may be on the menu more often.

“Walmart Q3 earnings show a distressed American consumer,” Quartz

Walmart just delivered a banger of a quarter. However, the news does not bode well for the financial health or confidence of American consumers.

In the third quarter, Walmart’s revenue jumped nearly 6% to $179.5 billion. Same-store sales at Walmart U.S. rose almost 5%. Online sales surged 27%. The retailer’s advertising segment saw sales climb over 30%. Memberships grew 9%. Operating costs rose slightly, but gross margins increased by two percentage points.

Walmart raised its full-year sales and operating-income outlook

All in all? It is a quarter to make you think American shoppers are happily piling goods into their carts right across the nation.

The problem is what’s behind those numbers. A massive, economy-wide trade-down is occurring. When U.S. households feel squeezed by job insecurity, inflation, tariffs, rising debt burdens, or perhaps all of the above. They change where they shop.

Middle and upper-income households switch from Target and regional competitors to Walmart, Earnings from both retailers this week make it clear that’s exactly what’s happening now.

Grocery gains tell the greatest part of the story

Grocery was the engine of Walmart’s quarter, and grocery-led comps almost never signal a confident consumer. Instead, they’re a sign that shoppers are moving down the value ladder, buying fresh produce and pastries from Chez Sam Walton, defecting from regional grocers and mid-tier retailers, and buying more essentials while cutting back on discretionary categories. Walmart itself noted strength in the “customer value proposition with everyday low prices and increased convenience,” code for customers trying to stretch every paycheck just a little bit farther.

Target is seeing the downside of this behavior, and watching sales shrink quarter by quarter, with management already predicting a challenging environment during the all-important holiday season. Store traffic is falling, and management is preparing for a negative sales growth despite rolling out 20,000 new seasonal items.

Two sides of the same economic picture

Walmart’s success and Target’s struggle are two sides of the same consumer story: the middle and upper-middle are under financial pressure significant enough to change their behavior on a mass scale. They’re not thriving. They’re optimizing amid tight conditions.

In this light, Walmart’s banger of a quarter shows growing strain and contracting confidence.

American shoppers are looking for deals on bread and bananas. They’re bulk-buying at Sam’s Club, shifting to store brands, and relying more on pickup and delivery to control spending. That helps Walmart. But it hurts almost everyone else.

~~~~~~~

Just recalled another store which might be more likely frequented now due to higher prices than previously. Every once and a while my wife would visit Aldi’s. The prices were less than the trade-marked stores also. Brief note:

Key stat: Foot traffic to Aldi stores grew 12.3% YoY in Q4 2024, over twice the growth of low-cost competitor Trader Joe’s, according to data from Placer.ai. Some stats . . .

• Aldi opened nearly 120 stores across the US last year and plans to add 225 more to its store count in 2025, making it the third-largest grocery chain in the country, according to the retailer.
• As a discount retailer, Aldi is well-positioned to weather 2025’s challenging economic climate. 69% of consumers report looking for sales/deals/coupons more often in response to inflation, while 49% say they’re switching to a lower-cost brand more often, according to November 2024 data from 84.51°.

In 2025, Aldi’s has experienced increasing sales also.

A study by AARP found a typical Aldi basket costs around $66.11 (£49.25), roughly 20 per cent less than rival discounter Target.

Even as inflation pressures ease, the threat of fresh price rises from Donald Trump’s renewed trade war agenda is expected to keep Americans focused on value. Aldi is moving to capture more market share, launching summer price cuts on more than 400 items.

For many consumers, less choice and lower costs have become a welcome combination. “It’s nice to not have excessive amounts of things to choose from,” says Sarah Campbell, a New Jersey teacher and Aldi influencer. “Especially when you’re worried about your economic future, you look for savings wherever you can.”