Fluoride ruling pushes EPA for regulatory action

Growing up and having Fluoride in the water was a big deal for stronger teeth. It was also in toothpaste. There is a whole industry that has grown up around the use of Fluoride in the water and in toothpaste. In Boot Camp, we were given a special and stronger treatment of fluoride. Now they are coming out with reasons not to use Fluoride above a certain level. ​

Global Water did recommend the water not be drunk by those under a certain age. (12?).

Senior Judge Edward Chen found the level of fluoridation chemicals that health and EPA officials consider “optimal” — 0.7 milligram per liter — “poses an unreasonable risk of reduced IQ in children.”

“It should be noted that this finding does not conclude with certainty that fluoridated water is injurious to public health,” Chen wrote, adding that his decision rather reflects “a risk sufficient to require the EPA to engage with a regulatory response.

What EPA’s response looks like can vary greatly, from a warning label to an outright ban.

“One thing the EPA cannot do, however, in the face of this Court’s finding, is to ignore that risk,” wrote Chen, an Obama appointee.

It’s the first time a judge has decided if a chemical poses an unreasonable risk after EPA rejected a petition asking the agency to do the same thing — a new citizen privilege under the 2016 amendments to the Toxic Substances Control Act.

It’s also one of the first times a federal court has been tasked with interpreting “unreasonable risk,” a TSCA term left undefined.

“This court looked at the science and acted accordingly. Now the EPA must respond by implementing new regulations that adequately protect all Americans. Especially our most vulnerable infants and children from this known health threat.”

EPA spokesperson Remmington Belford said the agency “is reviewing the decision,” and did not answer whether or not it will appeal the decision.

Approximately 75 percent of the U.S. population gets their drinking water from public systems with fluoridated chemicals. Local authorities have been fluoridating tap water systems since the 1940s, at the advice of public health officials who championed the chemicals for fighting tooth decay and cavities.

Research has long shown that high concentrations can lead to weaker bones and impaired brain development.

EPA has regulated fluoride in drinking water since 1986, capping concentrations at a maximum of 4 milligrams per liter. Water systems with levels above 2 milligrams per liter must provide public notice.