U.C.-Berkeley law professor Goodwin Liu’s nomination to the Ninth Circuit Court of appeals was killed a couple years ago by Senate Republicans upon the pretext that Lui had trashed Alito to the Senate Judiciary Committee in testimony during Alito’s confirmation hearing. Lui predicted that Alito as a justice would be exactly what Alito as a justice is. Now that Lui’s prediction has proven spot-on*, Obama should nominate him, not for the Ninth Circuit but for Supreme Court upon Ginsburg’s retirement in a year or two.
It would be at least some small poetic justice for this justice.
But Alito’s demeaning, denigrating treatment of litigants and counsel is emblematic of a veritable hallmark of the Federalist Society-affiliated appellate judges. Certainly not all of them do that, but also certainly, several high-profile Reagan/H.W. Bush-era appellate appointees have made that type of conduct a mark of peer prestige, and others, who don’t naturally have that personality—including some appointed by Clinton—emulate it. Something about being in with the in-crowd. It is, or at least for a long time was, the cool thing for them to do.
*The link is to a terrific article in Slate today by Mark Joseph Stern. But credit also must be given to the Washington Post’s Dana Milbank, who in a column published earlier this week was, I believe, the first of the now-several commentators to report on this.
UPDATE: I posted a similar comment to Stern’s article in the article’s Comments thread on Slate. In response, a commenter called Bigmouth wrote:
While I’d love to see Liu on the Supreme Court, I’d like to see the President pick fights he can actually win lol.
To which I responded:
This is one he would win if he chose to pick that fight. The high profile of the matter, coupled with the under-recognized importance of the generational change among voters–particularly the growing importance of the Millennials–and the overdue, very public highlighting of Alito’s votes and his conduct on and off the bench, would win it for Obama.
Not that I expect that lackluster, gutless wonder to actually pick this fight. But if he does, he’ll win it.