Yes, I am watching “The Longest Day” on TMC. Have not seen it for decades, but this 75th anniversary of D-Day seems to be the time to do it. This will be a rambling post all over the place. I note that according to the film, it was German Field Marshall Rommel who is depicted calling it “the longest day,” the day before it happened, seeing it coming.
I have been there several times, first in Fall 1953 when I was young and it was cold and rainy. Three times in1994, 1997, and 2002 I and my wife, Marina, took students to visit the site, always impressive and moving, especially the famous cemetery. In 1994 my late mother was with us and went around thanking veterans, who were visiting in large numbers as that was the 50th anniversary.
Unsurprisingly President Trump has been trying to get lots of attention for the celebrations of the anniversary, keen to hang out with the queen, who was actually around for the real thing, telling her how much his late mother admired her, one of the rare times we have heard him say anything about his mother. Supposedly Macron got more applause at the Portsmouth gathering that had the queen and even Merkel apparently, although not Justin Trudeau, even though the Canadians were a major part of the invasion. Putin was also not there (more on that later). I am not going to waste time going on about the usual stupid things Trump has said and done other than to agree with the commentators who find it appalling that he is draping himself in this when so many things he is doing and supporting go against the ideals of those who landed there that fateful and bloody day.
A curious coincidence is that today was the last day my wife, Marina, was teaching. She is now retired. For her final lecture she argued that trade is an alternative to war. Needless to say, this is something that Trump seems to be unaware of.
Before she went to class in the morning we heard a commentator on local radio going on about how this was the decisive turning point of the war, which would be followed by “our guys going to Berlin.” I do not wish to minimize D-Day at all, and certainly not the sacrifices of those who died there, but this is quite aside from the outright inaccuracy of thinking it was Americans who “went to Berlin,” this reflects a longstanding ignorance by many Americans about what really happened in WW II. It was all about us and D-Day, but as most readers of this probably know, the Eastern Front was the most important action, with many times more dead, and the Battle of Stalingrad the real turning point of the war, not to mention that it was the Soviets who got to Berlin first, although the other allies would get their pieces of Berlin later. Indeed, while later many in the US would complain about our letting the Soviets get there first and taking over so much of Eastern Europe in the bargain, in fact Stalin had begged the Americans and British to invade much sooner. As it was, the Soviets ended up doing the worst of the heavy lifting.
Which brings us up to Putin not being at Portsmouth, much less on Omaha Beach this morning. This is understandable as we did not send anybody to their big memorial of the war, Victory Day, May 9. This has long been one of the biggest holidays of the year in Moscow, both under Soviet rule and since under Russian rule. As it was, after the end of the USSR there was a period when the military parades were cut back and even eliminated, although it remained a big celebration. But recently Putin has reinstated them. The war is being increasingly emphasized as a national inspiration, and Stalin is being rehabilitated big time. Nevertheless, at this year’s military parades on Red Square, there was only one foreign leader, with him in fact officially stepping down, although into a superior position still in ultimate control, Nursultan Nazarbaev of Kazakhstan, the last ruler of a former Soviet republic to have actually run his republic under Soviet rule as local Communist Party leader. So, no surprise Putin did not show up for the D-Day celebrations, having a meeting in Moscow with China’s Xi Jinping instead.
As for Trump, well, he is spending the night at his gold course in Ireland for a second evening before he heads back to Washington so he can declare a new national emergency to save us from all rhose illegal immigrants coming in from Mexico. Bring on the tariffs says our bone spur leader!
Barkley Rosser
“he is spending the night at his gold course in Ireland”
It won’t be gold once he is out of office.
His income will plunge dramatically on February 1st.
“As it was, the Soviets ended up doing the worst of the heavy lifting”
The Soviet Union’s military deaths during WWI were about 9 million. No other country suffered those kinds of losses. But the Soviet Union’s losses were that awful because Joseph Stalin had killed off the best of his officer corps during his paranoid purges.
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Purge
That became obvious when the huge Soviet army took 2 months to subdue tiny Finland.
The Soviet army finally stopped the German army after Stalin ordered that anyone retreating was to be shot. With that kind of encouragement they could order failed counter attacks on German forces and TAKE HUGE LOSSES.
Soviet Casualties 1941–1945 According to Field Reports
Description ——— Irrecoverable losses
1941 3rd Q ————— 2,129,677
1941 4th Q ————— 1,007,996
1942 1st Q ————— 675,315
1942 2nd Q ————— 842,898
1942 3rd Q ————— 1,224,495
1942 4th Q ————— 515,508
1943 1st Q ————— 726,714
1943 2nd Q ————— 191,904
1943 3rd Q ————— 803,856
1943 4th Q ————— 589,955
1944 1st Q ————— 570,761
1944 2nd Q ————— 344,258
1944 3rd Q ————— 510,790
1944 4th Q ————— 338,082
1945 1st Q ————— 557,521
1945 2nd Q ————— 243,296
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties_of_the_Soviet_Union
Note: Irrecoverable losses would be Deaths and Missing-in-Action.
For comparison here are US army deaths in WWII by quarter. Note that even the Battle of the Bulge only caused about 52,000 US army deaths.
1st Qtr 1943 ————— 7,597
2nd Qtr 1943 ————— 8,716
3rd Qtr 1943 ————— 12,197
4th Qtr 1943 ————— 13,122
1st Qtr 1944 ————— 18,132
2nd Qtr 1944 ————— 29,918
3rd Qtr 1944 ————— 48,917
4th Qtr 1944 ————— 52,855
1st Qtr 1944 ————— 50,922
The US army Major General commanding the US II Corps in Tunisia was sent back to the United States after the losses inflicted by the German army between Faid Pass and Kasserine Pass in Tunisia in early 1943. His losses pale to insignificance when compared to Soviet army losses during the same time period.
The Soviet Union’s military deaths during WWII were about 9 million.
Barkley:
Is it your contention, the Russians would have entered Berlin first even if a decision had not been made by the Three to allow the Russians to be first in entering Berlin? Ike stopped the western attack at the Elbe. Montgomery was allowed to continue to keep the Russians from Jutland and Denmark. Yes indeed:
“Berlin is only a political objective, not a military objective.”
We played out this comment by Ike well after he was gone in confrontations with the Russians either directly or indirectly in various places globally in deflection up till the unification of Germany.
Stalingrad was the turning point as the German Army was commanded by Fuhrer Trump I (Hitler) who was too maniacal to realize he was going to lose in pushing forward rather than pull the German army back. Then too, would the Russians have been in this situation if they had not aligned with Hitler?
Economic practices can be another form of war and used to force a country into submission.
My $.02